Huffington Post Responds (positively) to My Plagiarism Charge

This is a letter I sent by e-mail today to the author of an article in Huffington Post that “borrowed” heavily, without attribution, from work I have published on intelligence outsourcing in my book Spies for Hire and two publications, Salon and CorpWatch. I was outraged that a prominent publication would allow their authors to plagiarise like this. Within two hours after the letter went out, Huffington Post did the right thing by posting a new version apologizing to me and adding the correct attributions. You can find the corrected version of the article here. Thanks, HuffPost, for doing the right thing.

Dear Ms. Wedel:

I am writing to protest in the strongest possible terms your plagiarism of my work in the article published today, “Selling Out Uncle Sam.”
Specifically:
  • Your sixth paragraph about the revolving door (including the line ”the company that’s been called the ‘shadow intelligence community’ by a former CIA deputy director”) is lifted entirely from my book, SPIES FOR HIRE: The Secret World of Outsourced Intelligence, published in 2008 by Simon & Schuster, without attribution.
  • The quote in your seventh paragraph (“The Intelligence Community and the contractors are so tightly intertwined at the leadership level that their interests, practically speaking, are identical”) is lifted from my article, “QinetiQ Goes Kinetic: Top Rumsfeld Aide Wins Contracts From Spy Office He Set Up,” published in January 2008 by CorpWatch, without attribution.
  • The blow-up quote is lifted from both my book SPIES FOR HIRE and my article, “Former high-ranking Bush officials enjoy war profits,” published by Salon in May 2008, again without attribution
I demand that you publish an immediate apology, prominently, on the Huffington Post website, and make immediate corrections so the information in your article is properly attributed to me.
You have infringed on copyrights belonging to me, Simon & Schuster, Salon and CorpWatch. This letter will be forwarded to the relevant publishers.
I view this matter very seriously and will pursue every avenue to seek justice.
Cordially,
Tim Shorrock
Washington, D.C.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

Sidney Harman’s Intelligence Connection (It ain’t Jane)

Just posted, from The Daily Beast.

It’s well-known that Sidney Harman, the electronics mogul who just bought Newsweek, is married to Rep. Jane Harman, one of Washington’s heavyweights on intelligence.

Rep. Harman, a Democrat, spent eight years on the House Intelligence Committee and is chairwoman of the Homeland Security Subcommittee on Intelligence & Terrorism. She has had an intimate, and sometimes controversial, relationship to America’s spy agencies during her eight terms in Congress.

But few in Washington are aware that the real intelligence insider of the Harman family may be Sidney himself, through his connections to an obscure but highly influential organization known as Business Executives for National Security.

To read on, click here.

Update: the Washington Post’s Jeff Stein advances the story.

Posted in Corporations, Intelligence | 1 Comment

CIA Man

The CIA, Tuli Kupferberg and Me

CIA Man, written by the late, great Tuli Kupferberg, is one of the Fugs‘ oldest songs. I first heard it live at the Harry Smith Memorial Concert in DC produced by the Smithsonian Institution about ten years ago (I think that’s the version I’ve linked to here.)  To my delight, I recently discovered that “CIA Man” plays at the end of the Coen Brothers’ movie Burn After Reading. It’s worth it to see the movie just to hear the song.

It’s brilliant. This is the CIA of old – and probably now. Tuli helps us remember just how much damage was inflicted on other countries and our own national psyche by CIA covert ops during the Cold War – overthrowing democratic governments in Guatemala and Iran, collaborating with the Mob, paying off right-wing political parties from Chile to Italy to Japan, testing LSD on innocents – all the things that caused blowback that’s still with us. Tuli got it just right. I love his rhymes:

Who can mine the harbors Nicarag-You-A?

Out-hit all the hit-men of Chicag-You-A?

Fuckin’ A Man!

CIA Man!

I was very happy to meet Tuli at a seminar on Harry Smith’s Anthology of American Folk Music held the day after the concert above (the Fugs played because they were old pals of Harry Smith, who produced their first album). He was there with Ed Sanders and the other members of the Fugs, and I told him how I first heard the band back in high school in Japan, where me and my bohemian friends in Tokyo somehow managed to get hold of the most obscure music and magazines despite being thousands of miles away from the action. He was totally  open and friendly. Just after Tuli’s death last month, his musical comrades paid wonderful tribute to him and his songs at a concert in New York.

After our convesation at the Harry Smith tribute, Tuli and I struck up a short correspondence. One day I opened an envelope from him to find his lyrics sheet for “CIA Man” – along with a collection of cartoons and poems about anarchism, American imperialism and other stuff Tuli and the Fugs used to sing about with such verve and irreverence. Below is a scan of his song, with his corrections and changes in his handwriting.

The night they closed the Harry Smith concert (at Wolf Trap in northern Virginia) the Fugs also performed one of my favorites, “Nothing” (“Clinton a friendly nothing”). Listen carefully to this cut, from the CD from that great night of American music, and you can hear me screaming along in the background: “Nothing!” “Nothing!” The audience was typical Washington – staid, well-dressed, quiet as mice – and the Fugs’ raucous music, straight out of the East Village scene of the late 196os, didn’t seem to move many who were there. But, ah well, I had fun. I miss Tuli and thank our lucky stars that America can claim musicians like him. RIP.

Posted in Intelligence, Music | 2 Comments

My Turn: The Post Covers Spy Town (The Atlantic)

Just posted. An excerpt:

To be sure, the Post did the public a huge favor by showing, in excruciating detail, just how massive our secret government has become since 9/11, how far it spreads geographically across the country, and how many citizens are involved in its highly classified work: 854,00 people, or 1.5 times the size of DC. In fact, its reporting on the sheer size of the security monolith made the lead-off story one of its best of the year. Plus it was intriguing to learn all that insider stuff, such as the existence of “Super Users” at the Pentagon — a highly select few with access to all black programs in the military — and to read one of them comment that he won’t “live long enough to be briefed on everything.”

But the Post should have stopped after Part One and given it a rest. Looking beyond the numbers and the choice quotes from Bob Gates, Leon Panetta and other high-ranking officials, the series is filled with the most pedestrian of reporting and reveals very little that is actually new about the privatized part of our national security state. It ended on Wednesday with an acutely boring piece about secret installations around DC that could have appeared in the real estate section (and will certainly not impress the Pulitzer judges looking for context and meaning). And when it came to reporting on intelligence contractors, the Post did not advance the story one iota. Indeed, I’m shocked at the paucity of new information and anecdotes.

For the full article, click here.

Posted in Corporations, Intelligence, Military Industrial Complex | 2 Comments

The Corporate Intelligence Community: A Photo Exclusive

By Tim Shorrock

(WASHINGTON, DC) – Not long ago, as I was preparing an article on government contracting, I was given a tour of Northern Virginia by a friend who spent over a decade as an intelligence operative and another five years working as an intelligence contractor. We drove through Arlington, Herndon, Fairfax, Tysons Corner and McLean, and up to Dulles Airport. Our route took us from the entrance to the CIA through “contractor alley” and past the huge, gleaming office buildings that house the dozens of corporations that make up what Lt. Gen. James Clapper, the incoming director of the Office of National Intelligence, likes to call “the intelligence enterprise.”

This industrial neighborhood is home to around 60 percent of the Intelligence Community. These are the private sector warriors who staff the offices and installations of the CIA, the National Security Agency, the National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency, and the rest of the so-called “Intelligence Community.” As I first reported in Salon in 2007 and later in my book, SPIES FOR HIRE, 70 percent of our intelligence budget goes to these companies. Officially, according to a 2008 ODNI study of human capital within the IC, nearly 40,000 private contractors are working for intelligence agencies, bringing the total number of IC employees to more than 135,000.

So here, as an introduction to the upcoming Washington Post series on intelligence contractors that has the agencies quaking in their boots, is a guide to the “real” IC (I’m sure the Post isn’t going to credit my work, so here’s my chance – with a little help from fellow muckrakers like emptywheel – to scoop the paper for once: screw ‘em).

Enjoy the ride; initial links to company names are to their section of the intelligence database I built with CorpWatch. All photos are copyright Tim Shorrock/2010.

We begin the tour: Ah, yes, SAIC, the Big Daddy of privatized intelligence, the company responsible for the failed $5 billion Trailblazer program at the NSA, which was supposed to keep track of the billions of bits of data downloaded by the NSA around the world but totally failed. SAIC, which recently moved its headquarters from San Diego to this building, stands like a private colossus across the whole intelligence industry. Of its 42,000 employees, more than 20,000 hold U.S. government security clearances, making it, with Lockheed Martin, one of the largest private intelligence services in the world.

SAIC’s offices stand in this office park, right next to its biggest competitor, Booz Allen Hamilton. Booz is involved in virtually every aspect of the modern intelligence enterprise, from advising top officials on how to integrate the 16 agencies within the Intelligence Community (IC), to detailed analysis of signals intelligence, imagery and other critical collections technologies.

Booz’s strategic role in the IC was best described in 2003 by Joan Dempsey, then the top assistant to CIA Director George Tenet for community management. “I like to call Booz Allen the Shadow IC,” she said when receiving a lifetime achievement award from a contractor group, because it has “more former secretaries of this and directors of that” than the entire government. Dempsey, whose picture is to the right (speaking at a contractor-sponsored event known as GEOINT) is now Booz’s senior vice president, responsible for many of the programs she managed while at the CIA. Booz itself it owned by the Carlyle Group, one of the nation’s most politically-connected private equity funds. Booz is also known for being king of the revolving door at the IC, as personified by former NSA Director Mike McConnell, who left the NSA to become Booz’s top executive on military intelligence, served for most of the Bush administration as DNI, and is now back in his old slot at Booz. So, not surprisingly, security is tight at this building; just after I took this picture, a pair of burly security guards came out and gave me the cold stare. I smiled and promptly left.

This collosal building, near the SAIC/Booz complex, is the headquarters for Accenture, the global consulting company that was formerly a branch of Andersen Consulting. Few people know (and you certainly wouldn’t pick up from their website) that Accenture is deeply involved in intelligence work. But as I learned at several industry gatherings I attended while researching my book, it does financial planning and audits for the IC and recently began providing information-sharing and collaboration tools to agencies. Its customers, according to Accenture literature I’ve gathered, include the NSA, the Defense Intelligence Agency, the NGA and the National Reconaissance Office.

Down the road, visible for several miles, is this Sheraton Hotel. It’s not a contractor building, of course, but it is where the CIA and other agencies like to wine and dine their contractors as well as visiting dignitaries from foreign intelligence agencies such as Britain’s MI5.

This building behind the trees is the headquarters for Scitor, a virtually unknown company that does over $300 million worth of business with U.S. intelligence every year. Scitor is “the biggest company you never heard of,” a former NSA officer who knows the company well once said (see the company’s profile in my book). It is a technology company that does extensive work for the Air Force in aerospace communications and satellite support services. The privately held company is also an important contractor for the CIA’s Directorate of Science and Technology. Within that directorate, it is used primarily by the Office of Technical Services, the secretive unit that develops the gadgets, weapons, and disguises used by spies. If you can divine anything from its website, you’re probably a spook yourself. So too if you can recognize these companies, whose logos are pointed out by my guide: Juniper,  Blackbird Technologies and RavenTech (so many predator metaphors!)

On the other hand, most people recognize BAE Systems, one of the many British companies that have made deep inroads into the U.S. intelligence market. BAE’s intelligence division has extensive operations throughout the DC area and operates numerous Sensitive Compartmented Information Facilities (SCIF) for intelligence agencies. These facilities have special windows that prevent outside infiltration of electronic spying devices. According to BAE, “Our newest facility in Herndon, Virginia, known as the Information Analysis Center (IAC) is a state-of-the-art workspace, built to stringent…customer security, communications, and analytic requirements. This facility, which was opened in July, 2005, provides over 150,000 square feet of accredited SCIF space accommodating over 700 personnel.” BAE provides much of its contracting services (especially to the CIA) through its Global Analysis intelligence unit, which described itself as “a leading provider of skilled, fully cleared, and experienced intelligence and geospatial analysts working directly with Government agencies and U.S. military commands to satisfy regular and surge requirements.” This is no bit player.

Not every building in contractor alley is marked. Only those who know can identify the headquarters of the DNI or the National Counter-Terrorism Center. But it’s easy to figure out which facility in the Herndon-Fairfax corridor is an intelligence center: the intense security just gives it away.

This building is reportedly a special intelligence office; next to it is a small building with a CACI logo on it. That makes the barricaded site even more obvious.

Finally, if you think that Dulles International Airport is just for the public, guess again. Throughout the complex are terminals often used by the CIA to whisk officials, operatives and contractors to their foreign destinations without being seen by ordinary travellers and with heavy security. That’s what this building is; my tour guide said he had used it several times to depart for the Middle East and other spots, both as an intelligence operative and as a contractor. Dual use, you might say, and a metaphor for the entire intelligence enterprise.

Then of course there’s the industry parties, where the contractors get to spend their money on lavish events of back-slapping and celebration. That’s what’s  happening here, where Stan Soloway, the executive director of the Professional Services Council, the voice and chief lobbyist of the contractor industry, is opening the “Academy Awards of the Government Contracting World” at the swank Ritz Carlton Hotel in Tysons Corner.

At this event, held every October, the scions of the Washington business community pay tribute to the leading companies in the government contracting industry. Like A-List actors at the Oscars, it’s the high-flying intelligence contractors that usually sweep the awards: at this event, in 2008, the big winner was Booz Allen, which was chosen best contractor of the year for companies earning more than $300 million a year. Booz’s competitors for the top spot were CACI International, which earns much of its money from the CIA, and CSC, another big NSA contractor.“This is the new face of government,” Soloway, a top Pentagon acquisition official during the Clinton administration, later told me about the 350 corporate members of his association. So who elected you? I thought.

The highlight of the PSC’s gala was the induction of Norman R. Augustine (below), the former chairman and CEO of Lockheed Martin, into the contractor “hall of fame.” Lockheed Martin, largely on the basis of its huge military and intelligence business, is the government’s largest  contractor, bringing in close to $17 billion in contracts in 2009 (see the rankings here). “There are fewer greater burdens that one could bear than accepting the fiduciary responsibility of spending the public’s money,” Augustine told the contractors. Ah yes, the new white men’s burden: spying for profit.

So that’s our tour. Enjoy the sites. And enjoy the Dana Priest-Bill Arkin series in the Post. It’s about damn time they covered this story: intelligence outsourcing to this extent has only been a fact of life in Washington since, oh, 2002. The real question to be asked of the Post is: why the hell did it take them eight years?

Note: I was a guest on Democracy Now! with Amy Goodman on July 19, 2010, talking about this article and the Washington Post stories on privatized intelligence. On July 21 I did a live Q&A on FDL/Emptywheel, talkin’ SPIES FOR HIRE and the WaPo.

Posted in Corporations, Intelligence, Military Industrial Complex | 24 Comments